Case in Point
Everyone agreed on the scope. They just weren’t talking about the same program.

You know the meeting. Everyone is using the word “scope,” but no one is describing the same program.
IT was focused on escaping an expiring SAP ECC support window. Finance was focused on transforming its own processes. Every other function running on ECC was simply expected to move to S/4 unchanged, even though employees would face a new interface and extensive testing would be required; yet none of that work appeared anywhere in the RFP.
Name the pain
This is a pattern I see again and again, and it has a name.
The Scope Alignment Illusion
Leaders believe a program’s boundaries are understood because everyone has agreed to the same words — while the critical work stays invisible in the space between those words.
The cost of inaction
That gap would not have stayed hidden forever. The system integrator would likely have found it after contracting and mobilization, but not before the missing requirements, testing, training, and change support became unavoidable.
By then, the CFO could have been confronting major change orders, a 6 to 12 month delay, and the risk of operating without support, all while explaining why an enterprise-wide migration had been funded as a Finance-and-IT project.
Why independent judgment matters
That is exactly the moment independent judgment earns its keep. Drawing on nearly 100 transformations across 30 years, I asked one simple question: “What happens to every other function running on ECC when Finance and IT move to S/4?”
After validating the answer, I helped take the exposure to the CFO, expand discovery across the enterprise, and put the real scope into the business case, the rate case, and the SI RFP — before bids were ever submitted.

Proof
I was serving in a Business Integrator role for a large, regulated utility, replacing SAP ECC with S/4. The planned transformation covered Finance and IT, but the migration would affect every function using ECC. Surfacing that disconnect before the SI selection allowed the client to add the missing requirements, scoping, testing, training, and change work up front, not after the program was already underway.
$50–$100M…
In previously unidentified implementation scope exposure and 6-12 months of scheduling risk were avoided.
